← Back to sermon library

The Usefulness of Confessions — Ephesians 4:1–16

Jim Butler · 2026-11-08 · Ephesians 4:1–16 · 8,834 words · 55 min

1689 London Baptist Confession

Summary

Confession study

A confession of faith is an indispensable instrument for the life of the church, serving to define, defend, discriminate, discipline, delimit, and historically anchor the doctrine that Christ has entrusted to his people.

A confession of faith is not a human addition to Scripture but a God-given instrument through which Christ's gifts to his church — pastors, teachers, and theologians across the ages — are preserved and put to work. Drawing from Ephesians 4:1–16, this lesson examines six concrete uses of the Second London Baptist Confession of 1689: defining doctrine, defending it, discriminating in church membership and office, disciplining departures from orthodoxy, distinguishing matters of Christian liberty, and developing a right appreciation for the history of the church. The session closes with the insistence that confessional Christianity is not sectarian narrowness but the faithful stewardship of truth that protects both the congregation and the consciences of its members.

Key quotes

A church with a little creed is a church with a little life. The more divine doctrines a church has, the greater its power and the wider its usefulness.
Men are seldom opposed to creeds until creeds have become opposed to them.
Heresy is not so great a sin as dishonesty. There may be honest heresy, but not honest dishonesty.

Applications

  1. Know the Second London Confession — it is a proven and practical tool for defining and defending the faith you profess, and familiarity with it grows more valuable the longer you walk with Christ.
  2. Insist that any church you join publishes a clear and detailed statement of faith; vague online creeds do not give you the information you need to commit to a congregation in good conscience.
  3. Resist the pressure to treat doctrinal distinctives as obstacles to church unity; the more doctrines a congregation agrees upon, the more genuinely it can endeavor to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace.
  4. Distinguish carefully between authoritative doctrine and pastoral advice on matters of Christian liberty; pastors speak dogmatically only where Scripture and the confession speak, not on questions of personal preference.
  5. Cultivate appreciation for the theologians and confessions of the historic church — Athanasius, Augustine, Luther, Owen, Spurgeon — rather than assuming the present generation must reinvent Christian doctrine.

Questions this sermon answers

Why do Reformed Baptist churches use a confession of faith?

A confession defines what the church believes, defends that doctrine against error, provides a basis for evaluating members and officers, and connects the church to the faithful teaching of Christians across the centuries.

Does holding the Second London Confession mean you think everyone outside your church is going to hell?

No — the speaker is explicit that justification is by faith alone, not by doctrinal precision, and that many believers in other traditions are genuinely saved; the confession defines the terms of membership and unity in a particular church, not the terms of salvation.

What is the difference between matters of doctrine and matters of Christian liberty?

Doctrinal matters such as the Trinity and justification by faith are defined in the confession and fall within church authority; matters such as diet or clothing are left to individual conscience, and elders have no right to impose their preferences there.

Why is an anti-creedal stance like 'no creed but the Bible' problematic?

The speaker argues it is itself a creed — and a deficient one — that leaves doctrine undefined, opens the door to heresy, and ironically reflects the anti-historical spirit of modern culture rather than the practice of the Reformers who affirmed Scripture's authority through confessional articulation.

How does a confession of faith protect ordinary church members?

By clearly publishing what the church teaches and where elder authority begins and ends, a confession prevents pastoral overreach into matters of conscience and ensures members know exactly what they are committing to before they join.

Scripture Reading

you can turn to Ephesians chapter four. Ephesians chapter four, I wanna read a passage of scripture, and then I wanna look at the usefulness of the Second London Confession of Faith. Last time, Cam went over some of the items in the preface to the Confession of Faith, and so as I have done several times as we've gone through the Confession, just try to highlight or articulate some of the reasons why a Confession of Faith is useful. in the church of the Lord Jesus Christ. And by the way, Cam is preaching in Surrey today.

Mike needed a Lord's Day off, so Cam is in Surrey morning and evening, so we'll remember him in prayer. So I wanna read Ephesians 4, verses 1 to 16. Paul writes, I therefore, the prisoner of the Lord, beseech you to walk worthy of the calling with which you were called, with all lowliness and gentleness, with long-suffering, bearing with one another in love, endeavoring to keep the unity of the Spirit and the bond of peace. There is one body and one spirit, just as you were called in one hope of your calling.

One Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is above all and through all and in you all. But to each one of us, grace was given according to the measure of Christ's gift. Therefore he says, when he ascended on high, he led captivity captive and gave gifts to men. Now this, he ascended, what does it mean but that he also first descended into the lower parts of the earth?

He who descended is also the one who ascended far above all the heavens, that he might fill all things. And he himself gave some to be apostles, some prophets, some evangelists, and some pastors and teachers, for the equipping of the saints, for the work of ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ, till we all come to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to a perfect man, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ, that we should no longer be children tossed to and fro and carried about with every wind of doctrine by the trickery of men in the cunning craftiness of deceitful plotting, but, speaking the truth in love, may grow up in all things into him who is the head, Christ, from whom the whole body, joined and knit together by whatever joint supplies, according to the effective working by which every part does its share, causes growth of the body for the edifying of itself in love. Amen.

Introduction

Now, this section doesn't say, here is several reasons why confessions of faith are useful in the life of the church. So my list here is a bit arbitrary. It's just as I've reflected upon it, as I've taught through this material before, and it occurs to me that I think that these are some emphases that are helpful in terms of a usefulness. But what we do find in Ephesians 4 is this emphasis on how the new humanity is to conduct itself.

In other words, in Christ Jesus, we've been saved, we've been redeemed, we've been blood-bought, we now have the Holy Spirit, and as a result, we are gathered together, not just as individuals, but as churches, and we're to function in a particular manner. And so there's this exhortation to unity in verses one to three, endeavoring to keep the unity of the Spirit and the bond of peace, just by way of a brief observation, You can't do that if you're not rallied around the same truth. You can't do that if you're not joined together with reference to what is the faith that is mentioned there in verse 5. If it's not grounded in the doctrine of the Trinity, this one God, this Spirit, one Spirit, one Lord, and one God and Father.

We can't have unity. We can't endeavor to keep that unity if we don't have this bond of peace. that is rooted in sound doctrine and truth and love. And then notice as well in verse 11 the gifts given by Christ to the church. He himself gave some to be apostles, some prophets, some evangelists, and some pastors and teachers.

That's not just with reference to the time that we live in. In other words, we can say this affirmatively that Christ has given, apostles and prophets in our own generation, but evangelists and pastors and teachers. He has done this for the threefold reason that follows, but He has done this in the history of the church as well so that we can remain instructed by the labors of those who have gone before us. And notice the threefold purpose in verse 12, for the equipping of the saints.

The old King James here is to be preferred in terms of punctuation. There should be a comma after for the equipping of the saints. That's one thing. The second thing is for the work of ministry.

And the third thing is for the edifying of the body of Christ. It's very popular in our generation to remove that comma and to say that what's in view in terms of the gifts given by Christ to the church has the specific emphasis of enabling the saints for the work of ministry. I believe that's true, but I don't believe that's what's being taught here. I believe that effective, faithful pastoral leadership should be equipping the saints of God to function in a capacity consistent with the gifts that have been given to them for service and work in the church of Christ.

But that's not what's being told here. The gifts given are for these three reasons. Four, the equipping of the saints. for the work of the ministry, those in the work of the ministry, and for the edifying of the body of Christ. Now notice, till we all come to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to a perfect man, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ.

And then dropping down, speaking the truth in love, verse 15, may grow up in all things into him who is the head. Christ, from whom the whole body, joined and knit together by what every joint supplies, according to the effect of working by which every part does its share, causes growth of the body for the edifying of itself in love." So in other words, you cannot do these things unless you have an emphasis on truth. And confessions of faith are about truth. Confessions of faith have been crafted by men that Christ gave to the church for the threefold purpose according to verse 12 and with reference to that maturation of the church in all our ages.

So confessions of faith, while not preeminent in Ephesians chapter 4, are certainly a corollary And so I offer up several reasons why we should use a confession of faith, and not just any confession, but the Second London Confession of 1677. Now, before we start, there's two book recommendations I want to give. One is a newer book, and it's very introductory, but it's very excellent. It's called Reformed Confessionalism, and it's by a fellow named D.

Blair Smith. So reformed confessionalism, it's small, it's yellow, it's probably at the bookstore here in Chilliwack. It's a great little introduction to confessional Christianity. I highly recommend it.

And then Crisis of Confidence by Carl Truman. It was previously published under the title as The Credal Imperative. Very excellent book, a little bit more detailed, a little bit more, not technical, but a little bit more advanced than the D. Blair Smith one.

And then there's an article, it's on the OPC, which is the Orthodox Presbyterian Church website, by Carl Truman, and it's a very helpful article, and it's called Why Christians Need Confessions. Why Christians Need Confessions. I'm gonna quote from him on two occasions in the material this morning. But

Defining the Doctrine of the Church

first, with reference to the usefulness of the confession of faith to define the doctrine of the church. to define the doctrine of the church. Again, we don't endeavor to keep the unity of the spirit in the bond of peace based on one faith, based on the truth of the triune God, if we don't have clear definition on what the doctrines are that we believe. Notice in 1 Timothy 3, 1 Timothy 3, in this, it seems as if Paul is invoking or calling upon a confession that was already in place in the context of Christ's church. which shouldn't surprise us in the early church. They didn't have Cambridge Bible publishers.

They didn't have Thomas Nelson. They didn't have the completed New Testament canon either. But had they had the completed New Testament canon, they wouldn't have had Bibles like we have today. And so confessions of faith, summaries of Christian doctrine, would have been absolutely crucial.

I think these were extant in the Old Testament as well, or at the time of Old Covenant Israel. There were lists of verses, there were lists of passages, there were lists of things that were for the edification of the people of God. So notice in 1 Timothy 3, specifically at verse 14, these things I write to you, though I hope to come to you shortly, but if I am delayed, I write. so that you may know how you ought to conduct yourself in the house of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth, and without controversy, great is the mystery of godliness. Great is this common confession, we might say.

God was manifested in the flesh, justified in the spirit, seen by angels, preached among the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up in glory. And then notice in 2 Timothy chapter one at verse 13. Some of these passages overlap with what Cam brought out two weeks ago, but I think they are important for us to appreciate. Notice in 113 of 2 Timothy, hold fast the pattern of sound words which you have heard from me in faith and love which are in Christ Jesus.

That good thing which was committed to you, keep by the Holy Spirit who dwells in us. So there's this recognition of a pattern of sound words. And so confessions and creeds are depositories of those sound words, in summary statement, biblically articulated, or biblically alluded to, and they are presented as concise helps to the people of God throughout all ages. In the epistle to the reader, again, we looked at this two weeks ago.

It is now many years since divers of us, with other sober Christians then living and walking in the way of the Lord that we profess, did conceive ourselves to be under a necessity of publishing a confession of our faith for the information and satisfaction of those that did not thoroughly understand what our principles were or had entertained prejudices against our profession. by reason of the strange representation of them by some men of note who had taken very wrong measures and accordingly led others into misapprehensions or us and them. And this was first put forth about the year 1643. So in the preface or epistle to the Second London, they're basically saying, we want you to know what we believe. We've been misaligned, we've been misrepresented, we have been mischaracterized, and we want you to know that we're in lockstep with our brethren who are Presbyterian and their Westminster Confession of Faith, and our brethren, the Congregationalists, whose confession is the Savoy Declaration.

Along the way, we will notice where we differ, with reference to baptism for one, and church government in another, with the Presbyterians and with the Congregationalists. But we are lockstep. This is a description, a definition, a delineation of the truth that we believe and we confess. As B.H.

Carroll made the observation, he's an older Baptist, He says a church with a little creed is a church with a little life. I often refer to my brother Roger. He pointed this out one time in searching websites for churches. He noticed, and I think he's right, because I've done this not probably as much, but I have done it as well.

You see a church's website, and for the creedal statement, it's about that big. It's that long. We believe in God. Let's do church.

And he also noted that the give box is always predominantly displayed as well, in terms of make your donations online. Thank you very much. But this isn't enough, especially in a generation like ours, when there's actually Protestant pulpits that are OK with homosexuality, or Protestant pulpits that are OK with women preachers, or Protestant pulpits that are OK with a whole host of departures from historic Christian orthodoxy. We need definition.

We need description. We need what B.H. Carroll says, a church with a little creed is a church with a little life. The more divine doctrines a church has, the greater its power and the wider its usefulness.

The fewer its articles of faith, the fewer its bonds of union and compactness. The modern cry, less creed and more liberty, is a degeneration from the vertebrate to the jellyfish and means less unity and less morality and it means more heresy. Definitive truth does not create heresy, it only exposes and corrects. Shut off the creed and the Christian world would fill up with heresy unsuspected and uncorrected, but nonetheless deadly.

He's right. He is absolutely positively right on that.

Defending the Doctrine of the Church

The second emphasis that I would see as an argument for the usefulness of the confession is to defend the doctrine of the church. We not only need to define it, but we need to defend it. Turn to the book of Jude. Jude 3, a passage that we should all be very familiar with.

Beloved, while I was very diligent to write to you concerning our common salvation, I found it necessary to write to you exhorting you to contend earnestly for the faith. The faith there is objective. It's the revealed system of Christianity. It's propositional revelation.

It is the truth. If not your subjective faith or your grip on Christ, but it's rather the church's grip on the truth of Christ. So I found it necessary to write to you, exhorting you to contend earnestly for the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints. And then notice in 1 Peter 3, same sort of an emphasis, 1 Peter 3 at verse 15, but sanctify the Lord God in your hearts and always be ready to give a defense to everyone who asks you a reason for the hope that is in you with meekness and fear.

And in both of those, Jude 3 and in 1 Peter 3, he's not just addressing the bishops in the church. He's not just calling upon seminary professors. He's not just calling upon, you know, the internet or the YouTube sort of apologists. He's not just addressing them.

He's addressing the brethren. He's addressing the beloved. And notice that Peter says, sanctify the Lord God in your hearts and always be ready to give a defense to everyone who asks you a reason for the hope that is in you. In other words, be ready.

Could be a seminary professor, could be a God-hating academic, it could be the lady at the dry cleaners. You need to be ready to give a reasoned defense of the faith that you promote or profess. It is absolutely crucial that the church is to have one mind and to be striving together for the faith of the gospel according to Philippians 1.27. And I would suggest that the confession is a very helpful tool in that regard.

If we're supposed to defend the faith, we have a description of the faith in the confession, therefore we have a basis for the defense of the faith in that selfsame confession. As Robert Paul Martin says, the confession is a useful tool for discriminating truth from error and for presenting in a small compass the central doctrines of the Bible in their integrity and due proportions. You don't have to read every book that was ever written in order to be able to defend the faith. Know the confession.

It's very helpful. The older I get, and I've been doing this for a little bit of time now, the more I see the value of the confession. I know that's anecdotal. I know it's sort of fatherly, grandfatherly, brotherly sort of a thing.

You should read the confession because it's really great. But man, take that for what it's worth. It hasn't ever proven me wrong. It certainly helped us in the midst of hardships and difficulties and trials and afflictions.

It certainly has helped us in the definition of sound doctrine and in the defense of that sound doctrine. Anecdotally, it's a great boon to any Christian ministry. It is a great boon to any Christian church. Imagine having to go it alone.

Imagine having to sort of bank on your own resourcefulness or your own innovative power capacity or your own creativity. Imagine if you had to develop a statement of faith for a church in the 21st century. That's a daunting task. And I think it's an arrogant task on the part of those who say, well, we don't need the 20 centuries of gifts given by Christ to his church because we can do it now and we can do it better.

I say, That is just not a legit attitude when it comes to this whole idea of defending the faith.

Discriminating in Membership and Office

I would suggest, thirdly, it's a helpful tool to discriminate with reference to the doctrine of the church. Discrimination is one of those words that we always load up with negative connotations. Discrimination means, typically, that I have a problem with other races. Discrimination typically means that I have a problem with other peoples based on their ethnicity.

Discrimination means to distinguish. It means to be able to observe and make distinctions. It means to be able to see what is necessary to see, and that's how I'm using it. So to discriminate with reference to the doctrine of the church on the part of the membership.

Again, brethren, the confessing of this confession does not commit us to anathematizing every other Christian tradition out there. That's an unfortunate thing. Oh, you're one of those Baptists that hold to the confession. You don't think anybody's saved.

I've never said that. I have never believed that. I believe that there's a whole host of people saved, and I rejoice that it's justification by faith alone and not by our appropriation of God's truth. I'm very thankful that we don't get into heaven based on our doctrine all night long.

I'm saying this generally. Of course we do in terms of justification by faith. There's a lot of weird people and a lot of weird things out there that Christians hold to. But nevertheless, the blood of Jesus Christ, the son of God cleanses them from all sin.

So the confession of a particular confession does not mean a consignment of everybody else into hell. It just doesn't. But if we're gonna endeavor to keep the unity of the spirit and the bond of peace, if we recognize collectively that there's one faith grounded in the glory of the triune God, then it should be the case that we agree on a lot of things when we do church together, right? It just seems to follow to me necessarily.

In other words, if you are a charismatic or a Pentecostal that believes in ongoing continual revelatory gifts in terms of prophesying and tongue speaking, This is probably not the church for you. If you are an Arminian, if you think that free will is the primary emphasis with reference to salvation, this ain't gonna be your cup of tea. If you are dispensational in your orientation in terms of hermeneutics and sort of an end time expectation or the relevance of the place of the Jews in the New Covenant era, this most likely isn't gonna be the church for you. That doesn't mean you're going to hell That doesn't mean the lake of fire awaits you.

It simply means that as those bound together, endeavoring to keep the unity of the spirit and the bond of peace, the idea is, is that the more doctrines we can agree on, the easier it becomes to endeavor to keep the unity of the spirit and the bond of peace, recognizing one faith the way that we do. So we need to be able to discriminate. And I think it is unfair for a church not to publish a statement of their faith. If I'm out church shopping, I wanna know what I'm getting myself into.

I wanna know if it's Arminian. I wanna know if it's Pelagian. I wanna know if a woman's gonna preach. I wanna know if there's gonna be tongue speaking.

I wanna know that. If you don't tell me that, you're being unfair. But a church that publishes what she believes, a church that tells you what is necessary, again, not for salvation, But for membership and a particular expression of Christ's local church, that's just right. It's just honest.

It's just faithful. It's just decent. You don't get people in. by shrouding or clouding what it is that you teach. You tell them, this is what we believe.

I've had to do that with people that have visited our church. I know where they've come from and I know what their particular backgrounds are. I know that their church life has differed significantly. And I've told them at the outset, we believe that believers are saved.

But I also think that you're gonna struggle here. You're a dispensationalist. and you're gonna hear me preach on the threefold use of the law and the threefold division of the law, you're probably gonna have some struggles with that. You're free to stay, you're free to deal, but just know we're not gonna change, and just know that it may not be the most pleasant thing you've ever heard. I had to do that with Arminians, I get it.

You believe that free will reigns supreme, but that ain't what we teach. We believe alongside of Owen that that's a bad thing, and we believe in the supremacy of God's will. So I think that's good. I don't wanna say, well, you'll be fine here.

No, you'll be fine here if it's only about our profession of faith in Jesus, but if you're gonna be upset by a particular truth taught, you should know that, just like I'd wanna know. If I went to an Arminian Pentecostal tongue-speaking church, I'd want them to tell me. We're gonna speak in tongues while we're praising free will. I'm gonna know this is likely not the place for me.

Or baptism. We practice believer's baptism. I have heard it on a few occasions. If you just sacrifice that requirement, your church would be a lot bigger.

We can't sacrifice that requirement. This is what the Bible teaches. One Lord, one faith, one baptism. We're not going to change things up.

This is what we believe. If you're a paedo-baptist that thinks this is the best game in town, praise God. You're welcome to be here, but just know it might violate your consciences if we don't baptize babies and if we baptize believers. And in the course of that, make a few derogatory statements about the practice of infant baptism.

Sorry. It's just life in the church of Christ. I don't doubt for a moment that paedo-baptist churches make derogatory comments about the practice of a believer's baptism. I'm okay with that.

It doesn't hurt me. It doesn't send me into an asylum. It causes me to reflect upon the reality that brothers hold their principles, for which I praise God. That's the emphasis.

We need to be able to discriminate with reference to the doctrine of the church. Again, Dr. Martin. The Bible envisages the local church, not as a union of those who have agreed to differ, but as a body marked by peace and unity.

That's crucial. That's absolutely crucial. The Great Commission demands that local churches instruct Christ's sheep in those things he commanded. The apostle demands that such instruction be truthful and produce unity.

The practice of discrimination is not to starve the hungry, but it's rather to chase away the dangerous. Andrew Fuller said, the object of articles of faith is to keep at a distance, not those who are weak in the faith, but such as are its avowed enemies. So to make this clear, it's not like you have to believe every jot and tittle of these 32 articles, and you've got to know how to explain them, and no, no, that's never been the way at a membership interview. You've got to know this is the position of the church, this is the doctrine that the church instructs us in, and if you don't have any objections to that, you know, by nature, then this is what you're gonna get, and this is what we hope to promote in you, is this kind of an understanding of what the scripture teaches.

That's a good thing, brethren, to discriminate with reference to the doctrine of the church,

Discriminating in Church Office

church membership, but also church officers. I've mentioned this. Wouldn't it be great if we had a handy little guide to help us to discern who's fit and who's not for Christian ministry? Oh, we do, it's called the confession of faith.

That's why if you've been at any of our I don't almost call it an inquisition. I think that's what Pastor Barcelos called it back in the day, the inquisitions you have seen. We go from scripture, confession. Why is that?

Because we're weirdos that are committed to one little truncated... No, because we believe that secondary, that confession accurately summarizes and articulates the truth of God's Word. So of course we wanna make sure that guys who are gonna step into Reformed Baptist pulpits, I know this is weird, but they should be Reformed Baptists. Again, that's not a condemnation to the Pentecostal pastor.

It's not a condemnation to the Netherlands Reformed pastor. It is simply the reality that if we are in the business of confessing what has been historically called the faith of particular Baptists or Reformed Baptists, then we want to train up men that reflect that, and men that preach that, and men that plant churches in accordance with that, and men that make disciples in light of that. Again, I wouldn't begrudge anybody else from doing that. Not sure why at times we're the weirdos, because this is what we insist on.

So the qualifications for elders. Again, Dr. Martin. And what I'm quoting is Dr.

Robert Paul Martin, his use and legitimacy of confessions of faith. It's printed in the beginning of Pastor Sam Waldron's exposition of the confession. Dr. Martin says, we cannot obey these admonitions simply by receiving the confession that a man believes the Bible.

So in other words, we need to discern whether a man is fit for gospel ministry. We need to make sure that he's fit for what Paul says in 1 Timothy 3, 2, he must be apt to teach. So he must have assimilated truth. He must be able to articulate the truth.

So Dr. Martin says, we cannot obey these admonitions simply by receiving the confession that a man believes the Bible. We must know what he believes the Bible teaches on the great issues, right? I mean, you're familiar with Jehovah's Witnesses, right?

They're anti-credal and anti-confessional. They say no creed but the Bible, which by the way is a creed. It just happens to be a really bad one. And for a group that says no creed but the Bible, they sure publish a lot of their creedal distinctions.

A ton. The Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. Tons of material that's creedal in nature. So if a man says, well, I believe the Bible, what does that possibly mean in the 21st century?

What could that possibly mean in the 17th century? What could that have meant in the 7th century? What could that have meant in any century? Well, I believe the Bible.

Really, I would suggest that a great bulk of people living in Western civilization would say, I believe the Bible. I mean, come on. That's like saying, you know, the Mona Lisa, what a hack. That's a terrible, terrible picture.

It's like saying, you know, apple pie is terrible. Of course I believe the Bible. Everybody believes the Bible. We must know what he believes the Bible teaches on the great issues.

A confession of faith makes it relatively simple for the church to inquire about a man's doctrinal soundness over the broad field of biblical truth. Without a confession of faith, the church's evaluation of its ministers is haphazard and shallow at best. and the church will be in great danger of laying hands on novices and heretics, all because it does not measure candidates for the ministry by a broad and deep standard. Again, I don't think any of this should surprise anybody here. Wow, I never thought of that.

Of course, it's self-evident, it's obvious.

Disciplining Departures from Doctrine

I would suggest, fourthly, the confession is useful to discipline for departures from the doctrine of the church, to discipline errant members to discipline heretics. Again, brethren, if you read the literature concerning the going up to Nicaea or post-Nicaea or in the history of the church, heretics at times sound very much like they're not heretics. They sound very much like they're not errant. So how do we get at it?

Well, I believe the Trinity. Okay, I mean, a lot of people say that today. Does that mean you believe that Jesus is co-eternal, that he is consubstantial and distinct from the Father? Well, no, I think he's a bit less.

Wait a minute, then you got problems in your Trinitarianism. Okay, you gotta confess the truth. And so with reference to departures from the truth, we have a helpful guide to determine whether or not members are heretical. Samuel Miller made the observation, whenever a group of men began the slide with respect to orthodoxy, they generally attempted to break, if not to conceal their fall by declaiming against creeds and confessions.

It's usually the first step. Oh, we don't need those old, dry, dusty documents. Do you hear what he's saying? The path to heresy typically starts by the rejection of orthodoxy.

Oh, we don't, you know, these guys, they were just men, they just put together, you know, they weren't popes or whatever. He goes on to say, men are seldom opposed to creeds until creeds have become opposed to them. If that isn't Jehovah's Witnesses, if that isn't every other group that has had a problem with confessions and creeds, that's exactly it. You don't denounce something that you agree with, you denounce something that you disagree with, or more importantly, that disagrees with you.

You can't have your cult, you can't have your prestige, you can't sell your books, when things like these are obstacles betwixt you and that. W.G.T. Shedd made this observation, and here he's dealing with people that confirm that they're confessional, but they don't hold to the confession. That's a whole nother problem.

There's people that say, oh, I hold to the confession, but they don't. I mean, they do, generally speaking, but there's some key points and key places where they don't. And that's scary, and that's dangerous. So Shadd is dealing with those who, on the one hand, affirm the confession, but on the other hand, deny what's taught in the confession.

Again, a big problem, and so this is what he says. Heresy is not so great a sin as dishonesty. Think about what he's saying. Heresy lends you in hell.

So that's the reality, everybody knows that. But his point is this. At least the heretic who isn't holding the confession has a bit more integrity than the one holding the confession while denying it. You get that?

When a Jehovah's Witness says, I deny the Trinity, OK, he doesn't say I hold to Second London. And I'm not commending him. I'm not saying he's not going to hell. But there's something a little bit more There's a little bit more integrity there than a guy who holds our confession and undermines the doctrine of the Trinity.

So that's what Shedd's dealing with. Heresy is not so great a sin as dishonesty. There may be honest heresy, but not honest dishonesty. A heretic who acknowledges that he is such is a better man than he who pretends to be orthodox while subscribing to a creed which he dislikes and which he saps or acts under pretense of improving it and adapting it to the times.

The honest heretic leaves the church with which he no longer agrees, but the insincere subscriber remains within it in order to carry out his plan of demoralization. Bigger danger. And again, one that I don't think is a made-up category in our generation. I think it really is out there, and we need to be aware of that.

Distinguishing Matters of Christian Liberty

I would suggest, fifthly, a helpful thing about the Confession of Faith, a little bit of audience participation or class participation. How many chapters are there in the Confession of Faith, without looking at it? 32, very good. Notice there's not 33, there's not 35, there's not 48. Notice that they didn't try to address every possible and conceivable thing that would ever face the Christian church.

My fifth point is to distinguish from matters of Christian liberty. The confession itself says in chapter 22, paragraph two, God, I'm sorry, 22.1. God alone is Lord of the conscience and hath left it free from the doctrines and commandments of men, which are in anything contrary to his word or not contained in it. The confession helps us address those things that are absolutely crucial for church life, but not those things that aren't absolutely crucial for church life.

Good brethren disagree on a whole lot of things and that's perfectly okay. Listen to Truman. Truman speaks to this same issue, but he addresses it from a different angle. He says that confessions delimit church power.

And I think that mine basically says that as well, distinguishing from matters of Christian liberty. Pastors don't have a right over your conscience when it comes to matters of liberty. They just don't. So the confession helps us.

Listen to Truman. In an age when words, especially words that make truth claims, are always suspected of being part of some manipulative power game, it is perhaps counterintuitive to think of confessions as delimiting the power of the church. Yet a moment of reflection makes it clear that this is exactly what they do. And the confession protects you.

I honestly believe that. I think a church without a confession is a church where the people are not protected. You need to know what you're getting into, you need to know what you're constantly under, and you need to know what you're being held to. Confessions do that.

Three lines on a website, they don't get at it. So listen, he says, yet a moment of reflection makes it clear that this is exactly what they do. An elder in the church has authority only relative to those matters that the confession defines. Thus, if someone in church declares the Trinity to be nonsense or commits adultery, the elders have both a right and a duty to intervene.

Both issues are covered for him in the Westminster Standards. But if someone wishes to turn up at a church wearing a bright yellow suit or decides to become a vegetarian, the elders have no right to intervene. They might have personal reservations about the person's sense of appropriate dress or wonder how anyone could live without the occasional burger, but it is not the church's business to address either matter. Indeed, this is what stops churches from becoming cults, clear and open statements about where church authority begins and ends, connected to transparent processes of exercising that authority.

Wow, bang on. The church does not have the right to encroach on matters of liberty. The church does not have the right to cross out of her lane into those things left by the Lord to the individual's conscience. The church is in her appropriate lane when she preaches justification by faith alone and pronounces you a heretic if you depart from that.

The church is in her lane when she confesses or professes or preaches the doctrine of the Trinity and says that you're a heretic if you depart from that. but she's out of her lane when you wear a yellow suit to church, or when you choose vegetarianism, or when you choose a myriad of other things that have divided and split good Christian people over millennia because we can't get it into our heads that there's an actual hierarchy of things that must be believed. You must believe who God is. You must believe the way that Jesus saves. When it comes to suits that you wear, when it comes to food or dietary regulations that you have, the church has no authority there.

The church cannot speak to such things. If you've ever called me and asked my advice, I typically make that delineation. I'm giving you advice as a human. I am not making a pastoral pronouncement.

If you ask me what color car to buy, I might say, I like blue ones. Don't buy the red one or buy the blue one and then be upset at me because you bought a blue one. I gave you my thoughts. But if you ask me to define justification by faith, that I say dogmatically and I stand behind because there's a hierarchy of truth.

I must believe that Jesus Christ died for my sins and was raised again. I'm free to buy a blue or a red car. Advice is not authoritative pastoral proclamations when it comes to things indifferent. And pastors that give it as such have crossed out of their lanes.

This is not a cult. If you've been here any amount of time, you know that I've always been sensitive to that charge that we're a cult. I recoil at the thought of that. That accusation, at least in my mind, has no valid basis whatsoever.

We have a confession of faith. There's no social manipulation or control. There's blue cars in the driveway, there's red cars, there's shaved heads, there's unshaved heads. There's all kinds of differences and that's the way it ought to be, brethren.

But when it comes to the confession of Christ and Him crucified, hopefully we're all lockstep and there's no departure, there's no differences and there's no distinction. When it comes to matters of Christian liberty, Christian liberty needs to be respected.

Appreciating the History of the Church

And then I would suggest, sixthly and finally, to develop an appreciation for the history of the church. One of the things that I like to point out whenever we do go through the confession and we compare what the reformers did with reference to what the medievals and the patristics did, we'll notice that the reformers didn't reinvent the wheel. When you look at 2nd London, 1677, they didn't reinvent the wheel. They took the best work of the early church, or the patristics, that means the church fathers, they took the best work of the medievals, and they incorporated that in their confession.

In other words, they didn't rewrite the doctrine of God. You jump into chapter two with reference to the doctrine of the Trinity, or you jump into chapter eight with reference to Christ the mediator, guess what? They're not doing new things. Where do you think they're leaning on or what creed do you think they're leaning on in chapter two?

Nicaea. Why would they try to reinvent that? Nicaea got it. I mean, it's definitive for the church going forward in terms of how to understand scripture with reference to the doctrine of the Trinity.

So the reformers didn't reinvent the wheel. They didn't do it with Christ the mediator. Where do they go? In chapter 8, they go to Chalcedon.

Why? Because Chalcedon nailed it. So we should follow them in that. They changed what needed to be changed, but they held to what didn't need to be changed, which gave them, I think, a healthier appropriation of the history of the church.

Has there been weird things in the patristic period? Or were there weird things in the medieval period? Were there weird things in the reformation time? Yeah, yeah, and yeah.

Are there weird things for us? Yeah, yeah, and yeah. I mean, they're all gonna look like absolute polished, perfect people after the history of our generation has been written. At least they weren't driving Harleys up onto a stage. to preach Jesus, or pastors repelling from the thing to preach Jesus, or calling Jesus a superhero.

I mean, what we do makes what they did look glorious. There's always gonna be oddities. But we should appreciate the history of the church. We should appreciate Ephesians 4.

Christ ascended on high, he led captivity captive, and he gave gifts to men. He gave Athanasius to the church. He gave Augustine to the church. He gave Aquinas to the church.

He gave Martin Luther to the church. But Martin Luther said this, that, and he, of course he did. Of course, all of them did. Again, are you gonna, in a hundred years, be able to reflect on, well, he only ever said what was right and pure and, no, it's just not possible.

Yeah, there's some strange and odd things in the history of the church, but that's our people. That's our brethren. That's the brothers that died and shed blood and fought for the fact that we have Bibles now and we have confessions. As Spurgeon says, the Bible is a blood-soaked book.

We don't just disregard, well, you know, they had a bit of an odd approach to church life. Okay. Did they explain the doctrine of the Trinity in a way that has stood the test of time, that accurately reflects what Scripture is? Yeah.

I'll take the weird hats. For Nicaea, I'll take the weird hats for Chalcedon. I'll take the weirdities and the oddities. We need to appreciate the church.

Moeller makes the observation, they, confessions, stand below, but also with scripture. They also stand above the potentially idiosyncratic individual and prevent him from becoming his own norm of doctrine. The non-credal, anti-confessional tendency understands the sola scriptura of the Reformation, in a manner that the reformers themselves never did and surely would have repudiated. The reformers would most probably associate much conservative American religion with the biblicism of Servetus and the Sassinians." He's bang on.

And again, Truman from that article, Why Christians Need Confessions. He says, we all know that Christianity is not reinvented every Sunday. That's a good reminder, right? We're not coming in to be innovative and creative and what's the new thing?

We all know that Christianity is not reinvented every Sunday. We all stand on ground that has been laid for us by many brothers and sisters in Christ who have gone before us. Yet often we can be tempted to live as if this were not true. This is hardly surprising as we live in an age where the anti-historical forces of the wider culture are powerful and all pervasive.

Whether it is a commercial telling us that the next purchase we make will bring us happiness or science promising some great breakthrough that will ease our lives, everything around us points to the future as that which is most important and certainly is vastly superior to the past. By contrast, Christianity is a religion rooted in history. It was constituted by God's historical actions culminating in Christ. And it comes to us through the faithful articulation and preservation of its message by God's Church throughout the ages.

That is profoundly countercultural and something of which we need to be constantly reminded. Ironically, it may well be that those who claim no creed but the Bible are actually reflecting merely the spirit of our age and all of its anti-historical triumphalism. In this context, the use of creeds and confessions is one intentional means of connecting ourselves to the past, of identifying with the church of previous ages, and thereby of relativizing our own significance in the grand scheme of things, which we need a healthy dose of, to be sure. The recitation of ancient creedal formulas in the worship service is one practical example of such.

And he also mentions, and this is from Crisis of Confidence, creeds and confessions inform the worship of Christians in a way that binds us all together. Worship is not about self-expression. It is about giving corporate expression to God and his reality. And when doing so confessionally and credally, it's with a glance at brothers and sisters that have populated the church from her inception.

Why would we think we're it? Why would we want to be it? Why are we such that we engage in what C.S. Lewis calls sort of a chronological snobbery, that it's only the books written in our age that have any merit.

It's only the books written in our age that have any value. C.S. Lewis points you to the past. He says, go read.

Go be humble. Go read the proven authors of the church in the past. It is the case. There's some good modern authors.

Truman, I think, is fantastic on these matters of intellect and Christianity and the expression of faith confessionally and credally. But brethren, don't neglect Luther and Augustine and Aquinas and Athanasius and Spurgeon and Owen. Don't neglect those guys and certainly don't neglect the confession of faith wherein men that I'm not trying to hurt anybody's feelings, that were smarter than us, put together Herculean tasks and carried out a good confession of faith. I'll just end with Spurgeon on our confession.

This ancient document is a most excellent epitome of the things most surely believed among us. By the preserving hand of the triune Jehovah, we have been kept faithful to the great points of our glorious gospel, and we feel more resolved perpetually to abide by them. This little volume is not issued as an authoritative rule or code of faith, whereby ye are to be fettered, but as an assistance to you in controversy, a confirmation in faith, and a means of edification and righteousness. Here the younger members of our church will have a body of divinity and small compass, and by means of the scriptural proofs will be ready to give a reason for the hope that is in them.

Be not ashamed of your faith. Remember, it is the ancient gospel of martyrs, confessors, reformers, and saints Above all, it is the truth of God against which the gates of hell cannot prevail. Let your lives adorn your faith. Let your example recommend your creed.

Above all, live in Christ Jesus and walk in him, giving credence to no teaching but that which is manifestly approved of him and owned by the Holy Spirit. Cleave fast to the word of God, which is here mapped out to you." When he published this for use in his church, that's what he said to the brethren as he gave it to them.

Closing Prayer

Well, let us pray. Our Father in heaven, we thank you for your truth. We thank you that it's so valuable and so precious that the church has seen the blessed privilege to protect it, to guard it, to summarize it, to articulate it, so that heretics may not have their way with your truth. We pray that you would bless us, give us a commitment to these things, cause us to constantly reflect upon the church being described as the pillar and the ground of the truth, not the experience, not the feeling, but the truth.

May you bless the children downstairs. We thank you. They're being exposed to the catechism at an early age. We pray that this would get in their minds and in their hearts by your grace and for your glory.

And we ask this in Jesus name, amen.

Questions and Answers

Any questions or comments? We have five minutes. I think that's about 10, five minutes fast or slow rather. Yes, ma'am. at the JW.org, they now do have a page that says what we believe, and it's quite lengthy.

I'm sure it's pretty long, yeah. Yeah, for sure. I mean, it's not a creed, but it's probably bigger than some churches. Just because you say it's not a bear when you meet it in the woods, it doesn't mean it isn't a bear.

So yeah, just because they say it's not a creed, it's certainly creed all. It's definitely quite lengthy. Yes. Yeah, in principle, yeah.

I have always wanted to talk to a guy who gets converted in prison. A guy who knew nothing about Christianity gets converted in prison and just reads the Bible and hear how he came out. Jim, do you remember Oscar? Yes.

Yes. His story was very similar. That's right. That's right.

That's right. He was pretty sound. He was, yeah, yeah. I mean, we didn't do any, you know, searching, examination of Brother Oscar, but he knew his stuff.

He had come out of a Muslim background. Yeah, I think it was J.I. Packer who said, when a person becomes a new believer, have them read John Calvin's Institutes before the Bible. And before everybody loses their mind, realize what he was saying.

Realize that there is a hermeneutic. And I think confessions and creeds provide for us a good hermeneutic of interpretation for scripture. So can it happen? Yeah.

Does it happen regularly? Probably not. So is it good in a confessional environment to disciple new believers with the confession? I'd say absolutely.

I think it's wonderful that the brothers have committed to teaching our children. I think it is fantastic. I think that it is great to get that sound doctrine and those succinct statements into them. If they're not experientially received right now, their data there, such that when by God's grace they call upon the name of the Lord, they have it.

They can say God is spirit, infinite, eternal, and unchangeable, and is being, wisdom, power, holiness, justice, goodness, and truth. They already have that sort of programmed in. I mean, I had Trinity stuff because I was raised a papist. We recited the Nicene Creed.

We recited the Apostles' Creed. I blessed God for that so that when I became a born-again believer, I didn't have to, well, what? Trinity, what? We take that for granted.

It's a big doctrine to try to make Simple and understandable to newcomers. Confessions help tremendously with that. Yes. There was a statement Truman made about reciting creeds in public worship.

Yeah. I want to do that. I just haven't implemented it. So just a bit of a foretaste.

Hopefully before I die or retire, we will be confessing the faith publicly. I think that's a very accurate or a very helpful thing for the church to get behind. churches and say like the Apostles created. Oh yeah, I think it's great. I think it's a good time for us to remind ourselves of what brings us together here.

So yeah, it's on the agenda. It would be a bucket list thing. I hope to see it implemented in the not too distant future. Singing, it's great.

That Apostles' Creed that we sang last week twice, or two weeks ago, we sang it twice. We sang it when Cam did the preface, and then I had it chosen for the evening service. That's a great format as well. But the recitation of the historic creeds is very, very helpful.

Yeah, I think that's a good thing. All right. Okay.

Scripture References

Study notes