← Back to sermon library

Ask FGBC #16: What is Free Will?

Jim Butler · 2024-07-04 · 803 words · 5 min

Ask FGBC Anything

Summary

Qa

Man possesses a will genuinely free from coercion, but after the fall that will is bound in sin and incapable of inclining toward spiritual good apart from God's regenerating grace.

Free will is affirmed in Reformed Baptist theology, but the crucial question is not whether man has a will, but what that will is capable of choosing given man's location on the continuum of creation, fall, grace, and glory. The 1689 London Baptist Confession of Faith (chapters 3 and 9) teaches that God endows man with a will free from coercion, yet after the fall that will is bound toward sin and incapable of inclining toward what is spiritually good. Regeneration liberates the will, and so evangelism does not appeal to free will but to God's free grace, trusting him to open deaf ears and hardened hearts.

Key quotes

The free aspect refers to the fact that we're not coerced. Our confession also says God doesn't offer violence in chapter three of the decree. So we are free from coercion, free from compulsion.
Free will is right, it's true, it's biblical, but it needs to be qualified in terms of where man is relative to his own sin and his place before God.
When we call sinners to believe and repent, we're not appealing to their free will, we're appealing to God's free grace, trusting, hoping, and praying that he will open their ears and their hearts to receive the truth.

Applications

  1. Recognize that evangelism is not an appeal to the sinner's free will but a dependence on God's free grace to open deaf ears and hardened hearts.
  2. Give praise to God for regeneration, knowing that your own turning toward what is good was his sovereign work and not the product of your unaided will.
  3. When studying the doctrine of man, do not neglect the fourfold state distinction — imprecision here leads to confusion in conversations about salvation and free will.

Questions this sermon answers

Do Reformed Baptists believe in free will?

Yes — the 1689 Confession affirms that God endows man with a will free from coercion, but the real debate is not whether man has a will, but what that will is capable of choosing in its fallen state.

What is the fourfold state of man?

Theologians distinguish man's will and capacity in four states: before the fall, after the fall, in a state of grace, and in a state of glory — each state determines what the will is free to choose.

Why can't fallen man choose God on his own?

Because the carnal mind is enmity against God and cannot be subject to his law, so fallen man's will is bound toward sin until God regenerates the heart and liberates the will.

How does Reformed theology understand evangelism in light of human depravity?

Preachers call sinners to believe and repent, but they do not rely on the sinner's free will — they appeal to God's free grace, trusting him to open hearts and ears.

What does Psalm 110 teach about the will?

The Psalm is cited to show that God makes his people willing in the day of his power, demonstrating that the liberation of the will is God's sovereign work in regeneration.

Okay, our next question is on free will. So how do we explain that differently than the Armenians? I don't know who wants to take that one on. Go ahead.

Yeah, so I just will start with an anecdote. I think when I was becoming reformed, I used to not think that we believed in a free will. And someone said, after I talked to him about Romans 9, well, what about free will? And I laid into him pretty good.

And I realize now that I didn't know as much as I should have, especially when it comes to really the doctrine of man. I know there's a lot of subjects we like to study, the doctrine of God, eschatology, salvation, but perhaps the doctrine of man kind of gets push to the side a little bit. And so as I understand it, with the nature of the debate in the 17th century, it doesn't really have anything to do so much with that we have a free will, but whether or not man in his state of sin can be inclined toward that which is spiritually good. And so we believe we have a free will.

Our confession talks about that in chapter nine of the confession. We believe that God has endowed us and given us that will. It's one of the faculties of the soul with the intellect, and the intellect and the will work when we choose, when we make decisions. And so I've heard it said that as the intellect knows, so the will goes.

And so we could say that the will is that desire, that inclination for that which is good, which flows out of our knowing that which is good. And the free aspect refers to the fact that we're not coerced. Our confession also says God doesn't offer violence in chapter three of the decree. And so we are free from coercion, free from compulsion.

So we do believe we have a free will and we were made and inclined toward that, which is good. But the problem is that Adam sinned. And so now that will is only inclined toward that which is sinful and wicked. And that's why we need it to be changed.

And so Psalm 110 does say that the Lord makes them willing in the day of his power. And so we praise the Lord that he does regenerate our hearts and changes our will towards that which is good. But we definitely believe that we do have a free will and God has made us with that will. No debate there, but really over what can man do in a state of sin.

Yeah, I think I would add to that too, there is free will, it's just where is man in terms of as a creature before God. So, usually we make a fourfold distinction with reference to man. Man prior to the fall, so what Adam had in terms of free will, and then you have man after the fall, what we have as a result of Adam's sin affecting his posterity. and then you have man in a state of grace and then man in a state of glory. So, the will of man is free, but man on the continuum needs to be located so that we know what it is he's capable of choosing.

So, as Mike said, in that state of sin, The carnal mind is enmity against God. It's not subject to the law of God, nor indeed can be. Jesus says, no one can come to me unless the Father who sent me draws him. So obviously the will is bound.

And so, we need to be freed, we need to be liberated, and that's the grace of God that gives us the ability then to will in the right direction, to believe on the Lord Jesus Christ. So, free will is right, it's true, it's biblical, but it needs to be qualified in terms of where man is relative to his own sin and his place before God. Yeah, so in evangelism and preaching, even though we know sinners are all depraved, and we know we depend on the grace of God that they will listen and will come. Right.

And I think there's a good sort of, at least an illustration of that at the gravesite of Lazarus, when Jesus issues the command, come forth, he has the power to enable compliance with that command. So, when we call sinners to believe and repent, we're not appealing to their free will. we're appealing to God's free grace, trusting, hoping, and praying that he will open their ears and their hearts to receive the truth and then come to the Lord Jesus Christ. Pete Yeah, perfect. Thank you.

Scripture References

Study notes

Confessions & catechisms

  • 1689 LBCF 3
  • 1689 LBCF 9

Theological terms

  • Anthropology
  • Bondage of the Will×2
  • Effectual Calling
  • Fourfold State of Man
  • Free Will×10
  • Regeneration
  • Total Depravity×2