← Back to sermon library

Ask FGBC #25: How do I handle family members, friends, etc, not believing?

Jim Butler · 2024-11-18 · 1,176 words · 7 min

Ask FGBC Anything

Summary

Qa

Believers grieved by unbelieving loved ones should persist in prayer and Scripture reading, while correcting the theological error that requires a prescribed crisis of sin and misery before a sinner may immediately repent and believe the gospel.

A questioner is grieved by family members and friends who refuse to believe the gospel, citing a theology that demands a prolonged crisis of sin and misery before conversion is credible. The response addresses both the pastoral burden of watching loved ones reject Christ and the theological confusion that treats immediate repentance and faith with suspicion. Practical counsel includes persisting in prayer, reading Scripture together rather than arguing theology, and pointing to the diverse conversion experiences in the New Testament and in works such as Pilgrim's Progress to show that Scripture nowhere requires a prescribed experiential cycle before a sinner may come to Christ.

Key quotes

Faith comes by hearing and hearing by the word of God. So, at some point, getting the gospel into a person's ears is absolutely crucial.
God is absolutely sovereign. Man is responsible and we need to teach both things.
You do not see that in the book of Acts. It's believe on the Lord Jesus Christ. It's repent, let everyone be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ for their remission of sins.

Applications

  1. Keep faithfully praying for unbelieving family members and friends without giving up.
  2. Invite resistant loved ones to read Scripture together rather than debating theology, since no one can scoff at the Word of God.
  3. Correct the imbalanced theology that treats immediate repentance and faith with suspicion by pointing to conversion accounts in the New Testament.
  4. Resist the temptation to respond to unbelief with irritation or theological attack; conduct and patient witness together form the appeal.
  5. Trust that God converts sinners in diverse ways and that a lack of a dramatic crisis experience does not invalidate genuine faith.

Questions this sermon answers

What should I do when family members or friends refuse to believe the gospel?

Keep praying faithfully and look for opportunities to share truth, and consider reading Scripture together rather than arguing theology, since no one can scoff at the Word of God the way they might dismiss a confession or your own testimony.

Is it biblical to tell someone to 'pray for a new heart' as the way to be saved?

There is no warrant for that formula in the book of Acts; the apostolic call is 'believe on the Lord Jesus Christ' and 'repent,' not a command to pray and wait for a crisis experience.

Does Reformed theology require a long period of sin and misery before a person can be converted?

No — the New Testament shows conversions without any such cycle, as with Matthew who simply rose and followed Christ at his call, and Scripture presents immediate faith and repentance as the normal response to the gospel.

How do I hold together God's sovereignty over salvation with the call to repent and believe?

Both truths must be taught: God is absolutely sovereign in regeneration, and man is fully responsible to believe now — neither truth cancels the other.

How do I deal with the grief of watching loved ones reject Christ?

Persist in prayer, avoid the temptation to attack their theology in anger, find common ground in reading Scripture, and trust that God saves in different ways and at different times as he sees fit.

Question Introduced

So this question, it's a longer one, but it provides some context and shows the heart of the person. So title, how do I handle family members, friends, et cetera, who are not believing? I've explained the gospel to them, but they don't care and they refuse to believe. They are waiting for a divine experience where hell is open to them and where they have a deep sense of their sin and misery.

They think they have to pray for a new heart, use the means, wait, and maybe one day God will convert them. They say they are dead and can't believe, but they also don't care that they are headed to hell. It has caused me a lot of grief and I don't know what to do anymore. I don't want to strain relationships, but I also deeply care about their souls.

I know God is in control and He does what He sees fit. Ultimately, I need to trust as if God can save me, for as if God can save me, nothing is impossible. Is there anything I could say to them? How do I deal with the grief of seeing them reject the Savior?

It's a great question and certainly I think one that pretty much every Christian can enter into. I mean the theological background might be a bit different. Yeah, I, you know,

Pray and Share Faithfully

keep faithfully praying for those people. As you have opportunity, share the truth with them. So, I do agree. I think Peter's admonition to wives that are with unbelieving husbands, it's through their conduct they may be won.

It's not through your constant badgering of them. Being a heartbeat wife doesn't, you know, put men into the kingdom of heaven. Now having said that, faith comes by hearing and hearing by the word of God. So, at some point, getting the gospel into a person's ears is absolutely crucial.

If it's the kind of a scenario where that's happened several times before, there's theological differences involved in terms of the freeness of the gospel, in terms of, you know, the deadness of the sinner and all those things, you know,

Read Scripture Together

another idea might be read Scripture together. You know, let's just read the Gospel of John together. You know, faith does come by hearing and hearing by the Word of God. So, where people may be a bit standoffish for me to pop out the confession.

Well, in chapter so and so, paragraph 8, it says this. You can't do that with the Bible. You can't scoff at the Word of God. So, whatever your theological background is, if you're in the realm of Christianity, there has to be a respect for scripture.

So, perhaps a person who's turned their ears, you know, a deaf ear to your testimony, your citing gospel truth, your good presentation of gospel truth, they might be open to reading Scripture. And, you know, I would say pick a very, you know, powerful chapter or section You know, I think of John, we're going through it obviously on Sunday mornings, but you know, the John 6 and the will of Jesus, or the purpose of Jesus to do the will of the Father who sent him. What is that will? To save those who believe on him.

So, you know, there's certain texts that I think are calculated to hopefully, you know, impact sinners. So, keep being faithful in prayer, you know, avoid the tendency, maybe it's my tendency,

Avoid Attacking Their Theology

avoid the temptation to get upset, irritated, and just attack their theology. I think that's, you know, but I don't think it's an attack on a theology to just show where it isn't biblical. You know, some of those conclusions are not from scripture. and

New Testament Conversion Examples

try to highlight, if I'm thinking about the backdrop to that question, the various conversions of persons in the New Testament. You didn't have periods of sin and misery when you were Matthew. You had Jesus say, come, follow me. And what did he do?

He came and followed him. So, he didn't, you know, well, I've got to you know, go check in for bed and see if my misery cycle is bad enough or whatever. It was an immediacy. You know, when Paul and Barnabas say, or is it Silas in Acts 16, believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and you shall be saved.

You know, those are clear passages that I think do devastate some of that imbalanced theology where it's looked at, you know, suspiciously if we tell sinners to believe and repent. If that's what God is doing through the Apostles in the book of Acts, telling sinners to believe and repent, then we should go thou and do likewise. Pete Yeah, I've got nothing to add to that one.

No Warrant for Praying a New Heart

Nothing in the Bible around praying for a new heart. God gives new hearts, in Ezekiel 36, giving a new spirit, a heart of flesh. But earlier in Ezekiel it says, get a new heart. It says to dead sinners that come to life.

So there's God's perspective, or God's side of it, the equation, and there's our side. Yeah, I've always thought that was a curious way to sort of present the gospel. Pray to the Lord for a new heart. You do not see that in the book of Acts.

It's believe on the Lord Jesus Christ. It's repent, let everyone be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ for their remission of sins. It's not, you know, there would be perfect opportunity with that Philippian jailer. You know, sirs, what must I do to be saved?

Well, pray the Lord for a new heart. Pete That's not the emphasis there. The emphasis is look ye unto Jesus and you will be saved. So, some of it is a theology of confusion that's basically been imposed upon Scripture.

Sovereignty and Responsibility

God is absolutely sovereign. Man is responsible and we need to teach both things. So, yeah, just try to get them into Scripture. Let's just read.

We can read without comment. We'll just read John 6. It's a good endeavor. Yeah,

Church Fathers and Pilgrim's Progress

scripture and then some of their own church fathers they follow. Sure. Like Brackle, he talks about some people do have a crisis, a very high experiences, misery conversion, and other ones are really very boring. That's right.

They don't even know what day or month or year it was, but they know they are in Christ, they are believing. Some have just been won over by hearing about the love of Jesus. That shouldn't be suspicious. There's different ways that we see in Scripture of various sinners coming to saving faith.

And then the other one is Pilgrim's Progress, so Christian had the big burden on his back, but nobody else in the book did. And then there's many characters in there, and they all had different experiences, as well as in the second part where his wife comes to faith, very different. So that's been encouraging to me.

Scripture References

Study notes

Theological terms

  • Divine Sovereignty×2
  • Effectual Calling×2
  • Means of Grace
  • Regeneration×2
  • Repentance×3
  • Saving Faith×2
  • Total Depravity×2

People cited

  • John Bunyan
  • Wilhelmus à Brakel