← Back to sermon library

Theological term

Penal Substitutionary Atonement

21 sermons · All terms

Oct 21, 2026

The Laws of the Unsolved Murder, Family Matters, and Dead Criminals

Jim ButlerDeuteronomy 21:1

Deuteronomy 21 addresses five distinct legal ordinances governing the covenant community of old covenant Israel: the unsolved homicide, female captives taken in war, the firstborn son in a polygamous household, the stubborn and rebellious son, and the hanged criminal. Running beneath all five is a single theological concern — the prevention of blood guiltiness defiling the land God has given his people as an inheritance. The passage is read typologically: the heifer sacrificed for the unsolved murder foreshadows penal substitutionary atonement, the charge of 'glutton and drunkard' leveled at Jesus in Matthew 11 echoes the indictment for the rebellious son in Deuteronomy 21, and Paul's citation of Deuteronomy 21:23 in Galatians 3:13 makes explicit that Christ became a curse for his people by hanging on a tree. The session closes with a Q&A discussion of polygamy, slavery, and the relationship between creation ordinances and post-fall civil legislation.

Jul 26, 2026

The Gospel Foundation for Corporate Prayer

Jim Butler1 Timothy 2:3–7

The apostle Paul grounds the church's corporate prayer in a three-part theological rationale drawn from 1 Timothy 2:3–7: the nature of God, the office of Christ, and the ministry of Paul. The phrase 'all men' in verses 1–4 refers not to every individual without exception but to all kinds of men without distinction — Jew and Gentile, slave and king — a reading demanded by Paul's own doctrine of reprobation in Romans 9 and confirmed by the scope of his apostolic commission to the Gentiles. Christ's mediatorship is shown to require both a divine and a human nature, and his ransom is definite in its design — paid for all kinds of men, not all men without exception — precluding both universalism and any notion of unmet desires in God. The sermon closes by pressing the congregation to show up for corporate prayer, to pray specifically for the salvation of those in civil authority, and to exhort all around them to flee to Christ.

Feb 1, 2026

2LCF Chapter 18 - Of the Assurance of Grace and Salvation

Cameron Porter

What does it mean to be assured of salvation, and is such assurance available to ordinary believers or only to a spiritual elite? Working through 2LCF Chapter 18, this lesson distinguishes true Christian assurance — an infallible certainty grounded in the blood and righteousness of Christ and the testimony of the Holy Spirit — from the carnal presumption of the unregenerate who rest on false hopes. The four paragraphs of the chapter are treated in turn: the doctrine stated, its pillars declared, the means by which it is attained, and the trials that may shake but never ultimately destroy it. Believers are urged to seek assurance through the ordinary means of grace, resting not on inward experience or extraordinary revelation but on the unchanging gospel of Christ crucified and risen.

Sep 7, 2025

2LCF Chapter 8 - Of Christ the Mediator, Part 4

Jim Butler

Chapter 8 of the 1689 London Baptist Confession sets forth the person and work of Christ the Mediator, and this study works through its latter paragraphs (4–10) covering the historical description of Christ's obedience, the specific operation of His atoning work, the retrospective application of redemptive benefit to Old Covenant saints, the communication of idioms, and the effectual application of redemption to the elect. The confession grounds definite atonement, active and passive obedience, and penal substitutionary atonement in Christ's willing entrance into the state of humiliation and His perfect fulfillment of the law, establishing the foundation for the confession's later treatment of justification by faith alone. The threefold office of Christ as prophet, priest, and king is shown to be not an imposition on Scripture but its exegetical fruit, meeting precisely the threefold need of God's people for revelation, reconciliation, and kingly rule.

Apr 26, 2025

CTF 2025 - Session 8 – Q&A Panel

Cameron Porter

A Q&A panel from a theology conference on the doctrine of God addresses questions arising from the preceding lectures on classical theism. Three theologians field questions on divine impassibility (including whether God can be grieved), the eternal decree and the covenant of redemption, divine aseity and the Son's relationship to the Father, the nature of time in the eternal state, the role of philosophy and natural theology in arriving at the classical doctrine of God, and whether genuine evil exists within God's sovereign economy. The discussion throughout presses for formulations of doctrine that protect divine simplicity, immutability, and impassibility while preserving the integrity of biblical language and confessional categories.

Nov 17, 2024

The Future Prospect of the Apostle

Jim ButlerPhilippians 1:19–21

Philippians 1:19–21 presents the apostle Paul's future prospect from a Roman prison cell, where he faces the real possibilities of release or execution. The sermon works through Paul's expectation of deliverance and vindication (vv. 19–20), grounded not in his own stature but in the prayers of the Philippian church and the power of the Spirit of Christ, and then turns to the great conviction of verse 21: 'For to me, to live is Christ and to die is gain.' The union Paul has with Christ in the present makes life a sustained magnification of the Savior, while death is simply the gaining of more Christ — a logic that dismantles every threat his persecutors could level against him. The congregation is called to the same orientation: to fight the good fight now, so that whether in life or in death, Christ is magnified in the body.

Jul 7, 2024

The Atonement at Gibeah

Jim Butler2 Samuel 21:1–14

The atonement made at Gibeah — where seven descendants of Saul were executed to satisfy the blood-guilt incurred by Saul's slaughter of the Gibeonites — is expounded as a typological anticipation of penal substitutionary atonement. David's inquiry of God, the Gibeonites' insistence that no silver or gold could ransom a murderer (Numbers 35:33), and the hanging of the seven men before the Lord all illustrate that atonement is the satisfaction of divine justice through blood. The sermon argues that Rizpah's grief beside the bodies of her sons is a solemn, sin-cursed scene designed to strip away abstraction and force the reader to feel the horror of what atonement costs. Only when the gore of Gibeah is taken seriously does Golgotha regain its proper weight: Christ, the greater Son of David, stood in the place of his people to quench the wrath of God and secure the covenant safety of all whom the Father gave him.

Jun 25, 2023

The Judicial Decision to Murder Jesus

Jim ButlerJohn 11:47–57

The Sanhedrin's formal decree to execute Jesus, recorded in John 11:47–57, is the most extreme miscarriage of justice in human history — a body constituted to administer God's law plotting the murder of the only innocent man who ever lived. The sermon expounds the irony that Caiaphas, driven entirely by political self-preservation, nevertheless prophesied accurately: one man would die for the nation, and not for that nation only, but to gather the scattered children of God from every tribe, tongue, people, and nation. John's theological commentary on the high priest's words (vv. 51–52) unpacks the doctrinal heart of penal substitutionary atonement — the just for the unjust, the holy and harmless for the thoroughly defiled. The passage calls believers to stand in awe that Christ willingly walked into this kangaroo court, refused self-defense, and bore the wrath of godless men so that sinners might be freed from the wrath of God.

May 14, 2023

The Conduct of the New Man, Part 3

Jim ButlerEphesians 5:1–2

Ephesians 5:1–2 concludes Paul's extended exhortation on the conduct of the new man (Ephesians 4:17–5:2), calling believers to be imitators of God as dear children and to walk in love. The basis for this imitation is theological: God is definitionally love (1 John 4:8, 16), believers have been adopted into his family by sovereign election and effectual grace, and family membership carries both privilege and responsibility. The motivation for walking in love is the penal substitutionary atonement of Christ, whose self-offering was an acceptable sacrifice to the Father — the antitype of the Old Testament burnt offering — and whose love supplies both the standard and the ground for all Christian love toward God and neighbour.

May 10, 2023

The Burnt Offering

Jim ButlerLeviticus 1

Leviticus 1 presents the burnt offering as the paradigmatic Old Covenant sacrifice, establishing the pattern of how sinful man may approach a holy God. The chapter addresses the costliness of sacrifice, the worshiper's heart disposition, the laying on of hands as substitutionary transference, and the meaning of atonement as the satisfaction of divine justice. The New Testament interprets this system typologically: the male without blemish, the substitutionary slaughter, and the sweet aroma of acceptance all prefigure the penal substitutionary atonement of the Lord Jesus Christ. Believers are called to read the Old Testament as a Christ-centered book and to worship God only in the manner He has prescribed.

Jan 9, 2023

Live Stream - January 08, 2023

Jim Butler

Colossians 2:11–15 teaches that believers are spiritually circumcised and made alive in Christ, finding their complete identity in union with him rather than in law-keeping, philosophy, or any other system. The circumcision made without hands — a heart-circumcision accomplished by Christ's death and resurrection — strips away the old man and brings the new man to life through faith in God who raised Christ from the dead. Christ's cross work simultaneously cancels the record of debt owed to God, removes the dominion of sin, and publicly triumphs over principalities and powers. Because the already-not-yet tension of inaugurated eschatology means remaining sin persists, believers are called to live as those who have died, been buried, and been raised with Christ — clinging to their identity in him rather than despairing under the weight of ongoing struggle.

May 29, 2022

The Conduct of a Faithful Minister

Jim Butler1 Timothy 4:12–16

Paul's charge to Timothy in 1 Timothy 4:12–16 sets forth the pattern for every faithful gospel minister: exemplary character, diligent public ministry, ongoing personal growth, and tenacious perseverance to the end. Preached at an ordination service for a newly commissioned pastor, this exposition works through each element of the apostle's command — from the six spheres of a minister's example (word, conduct, love, spirit, faith, purity) to the three pillars of public ministry (reading, exhortation, doctrine). The sermon insists that Christian virtue, however admirable, cannot save souls; it is the word of God, proclaimed boldly and accurately, that the Spirit uses as the instrument of salvation. The congregation is charged alongside the minister: receive the word with joy, reject heresy, prize the public means of grace, and honour those who watch for your souls.

Apr 24, 2022

2LCF Chapter 11 - Of Justification, Part 2

Jim Butler

The 1689 London Baptist Confession of Faith, Chapter 11 (Of Justification), paragraphs 3–6 are expounded in this Sunday school session, building on an earlier treatment of paragraphs 1–2. The study examines the basis of justification in Christ's penal substitutionary atonement and the satisfaction of divine justice (paragraph 3); the ordering of justification in time against the error of eternal justification (paragraph 4); the ongoing forgiveness of post-conversion sin in light of remaining corruption, with David's Psalm 51 as a case study (paragraph 5); and the uniformity of justification across both testaments, showing that Old and New Covenant saints are saved by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone (paragraph 6). The Westminster Larger Catechism's distinctions between justification and sanctification are brought in to guard against both antinomianism and perfectionism, and the session closes urging justified sinners to run to their Advocate rather than wallow in guilt.

Oct 3, 2021

The Crucifixion of Jesus, Part 3

Jim ButlerMatthew 27:45–46

Matthew 27:45–46 records the fourth of Christ's seven words from the cross — the cry of dereliction, 'My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?' — and its interpretation demands both exegetical precision and doctrinal care. The darkness from the sixth to the ninth hour was not a solar eclipse but a supernatural sign of divine judgment, recapitulating the ninth plague pattern and marking the moment the Passover antitype was slain. The cry itself does not imply any ontological division within the Trinity, any dissolution of the hypostatic union, or the suffering of all three persons; rather, it expresses the withdrawal of divine consolation from the Son according to his true humanity as he bore, in our place as surety, the full weight of penal wrath. Believers are called to ground their assurance not in felt divine presence but in the covenant faithfulness of the God to whom Christ still cried 'my God' even in the depth of his substitutionary suffering.

Jun 6, 2021

The Trial Before Pilate, Part 3

Jim ButlerMatthew 27:24–26

Matthew 27:24–26 records the sentencing of Jesus by Pontius Pilate — the culmination of a trial in which the governor thrice declared the accused innocent yet delivered him to crucifixion anyway. The sermon examines Pilate's hypocritical self-absolution by the washing of hands, the crowd's willing acceptance of blood-guilt and its ominous extension to their children, and the formal scourging and condemnation of Christ. Throughout, the exposition presses the double benefit of the gospel: the forgiveness of sins and the imputation of Christ's righteousness received by faith alone, both grounded in the penal substitutionary atonement symbolised by Barabbas going free while the just one goes to the cross.

Nov 8, 2020

The Cross Predicted and Rejected

Mike Kirkpatrick

Mark 8:31-33 records Jesus' first explicit prediction of His suffering, death, and resurrection — a proclamation that shattered every nationalist expectation of a triumphant Messiah. The sermon works through two movements: the cross predicted (vv. 31-32a), where Jesus identifies Himself as the suffering Son of Man whose death and resurrection were decreed by God from eternity, and the cross rejected (vv. 32b-33), where Peter's rebuke earns the reply 'Get behind me, Satan' because man's thoughts about the Messiah stand in direct opposition to God's. Rooted in Isaiah 53, Daniel 7, Hosea 6, and Psalm 118, the exposition argues that penal substitutionary atonement — the Son of Man bearing the wrath sinners deserve — is the only ground of eternal life, and that the same Christ who prepared His disciples for His own suffering now calls His people to take up their crosses in this present evil age.

May 24, 2020

The Manifestation of God's Grace

Jim ButlerTitus 2:11–15

Titus 2:11–15 presents God's grace not merely as the ground of salvation but as the very teacher of holy living. This exposition traces four aspects of grace in the passage: its appearance in the incarnation and atoning work of Christ, its instruction toward denial of ungodliness and worldly lusts and pursuit of sober, righteous, and godly life, its demonstration in the deity of the returning Christ and the definite redemption he accomplished, and its proclamation through authoritative gospel ministry. The controlling hermeneutical key is the grammatical and theological priority of the indicative over the imperative: believers obey not in order to be saved but because they have been saved, and inverting that order collapses the gospel into moralism.

Dec 10, 2017

The Christian's Spiritual State

Mike Kirkpatrick1 John 2:12–14

What is the true spiritual state of God's children, regardless of how they feel in the midst of trials and false teaching? Expounding 1 John 2:12–14, this sermon identifies three present realities that belong to every believer: the forgiveness of sins grounded in Christ's propitiatory work, the knowledge of the gospel through union with Him who is from the beginning, and spiritual strength over the evil one because Christ has conquered the devil on behalf of His people. The application is that these are not aspirational goals but fixed heavenly realities already secured in Christ, and they are to be the source of assurance and courage in daily battle against sin and temptation.

Jul 23, 2017

The Hearing before the Sanhedrin, Part 1

Jim ButlerMatthew 26:57–61

Matthew 26:57–61 places Jesus before the Sanhedrin in what the preacher demonstrates was not an impartial criminal trial but a predetermined hearing whose guilty verdict had been settled before any witnesses were called. The sermon maps the political and ecclesiastical machinery of the Sanhedrin — its composition, its lack of authority to execute, its violations of due process, and its need to construct a charge sufficient to deliver Jesus to Pilate — and addresses the charge that the gospel accounts of these events are colored by anti-Semitism. Against that background, the contrast between the faithful witness of Christ and the fearful, distanced discipleship of Peter issues a direct call to close, unashamed allegiance to the Savior, and an invitation to unbelievers to come to the One who restores even those who deny him.

Audio
Mar 6, 2013

Deuteronomy 29

Jim ButlerDeuteronomy 29

Deuteronomy 29 records Moses' third and final address to Israel on the plains of Moab, structured as a covenant renewal ceremony before the people enter Canaan. The sermon traces three movements in the chapter: a historical review of God's redemptive acts (the Exodus, the wilderness, the defeat of Sihon and Og), the terms and central promise of the covenantal bond ('I will be their God and they shall be my people'), and a solemn warning against apostasy and idolatry, with its attendant curses culminating in exile. The sermon situates these three elements within the broader covenantal structure of Scripture, from the covenant with Adam through the new covenant announced in Deuteronomy 30, and concludes by pointing to Christ as the one who bore the covenant curses in the place of his people through penal substitutionary atonement.

Audio
Mar 22, 2009

We Esteemed Him Not

Cameron PorterIsaiah 53:3

Isaiah 53:3 contains a startling corporate confession: 'He was despised and we did not esteem Him.' This sermon works through that verse in its full context, first establishing that Isaiah 53 speaks exclusively of the penal substitutionary work of Jesus Christ, then examining four questions about biblical esteem — that we did not esteem Him, why we did not, why we now do, and why He is worthy of highest esteem. The explanation for both our former contempt and our present esteem rests entirely on sovereign grace: men by nature are dead in trespasses and sins, and it is God alone who makes the dead alive, producing the faith by which Christ becomes precious to His people. The sermon closes with a call to revive a love for Christ, to pray for rulers, and to warn the unconverted that the same Christ who is 'altogether lovely' to believers will be a terror to those who refuse to bend the knee.